Superlawyer Badges
AV Preeminent Badge
AVVO Rating 10.0 - Top Attorney Criminal Defense
AVVO Rating 10.0 - Top Attorney Personal Injury
AVVO Top Contributor - Criminal Defense
AVVO Clients' Choice - Car Accidents
AVVO Top Contributor - Family
AVVO Clients' Choice - Criminal Defense
BBB

Rockwall Car Accident Damages Upheld On Appeal

The Dallas Court of Appeals upheld a ruling for damages from a Rockwall Car Accident case. The case ROBERT MILLER, Appellant vs. MATTHEW AARON CHURCHES, Appellee was tried before a jury in the 382nd Judicial District Court in Rockwall County.

What happened?

Matthew Aaron Charles, the Defendant, was found responsible for a car accident in Rockwall in which Robert Miller, the Plaintiff, was injured. Robert Miller sued Mr. Charles and they had a jury trial.

From the opinion-

The jury awarded Miller $23,810.45 for past medical expenses and past physical pain. The jury declined to award him damages for future medical expenses or future physical pain, and it declined to award any damages for loss of earning capacity or physical impairment. Miller appeals, contending the evidence is factually insufficient to support the jury’s award. Specifically, Miller complains of the jury’s failure to compensate him adequately for purportedly accident-related injuries to his hip, lower back, and neck.

Miller appealed the verdict and asked that the appellate court overturn this result and allow him to recover for his future medical expenses and his hip, back and neck injuries.

What’s the law say about asking for medical expenses and damages for car wreck injuries on appeal? Basically, the law favors not overturning a factual finding unless there is great evidence to the contrary.

From the opinion-

When a party attacks the factual sufficiency of an adverse finding on an issue on which he had the burden of proof, he must demonstrate on appeal that the adverse finding is against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence. Dow Chem. Co. v. Francis, 46 S.W.3d 237, 242 (Tex. 2001). We consider and weigh all of the evidence, and we will set aside a verdict on the issue only if the evidence is so weak or if the finding is so against the great weight and preponderance of the evidence that it is clearly wrong and unjust. Id.

Miller had a pre existing condition in his spine and hip prior to the accident, and had underwent spinal fusion surgery. Still, miller was able to work up until the accident. Miller argued that the accident caused further injuries to his condition and made it impossible for him to continue working. The Defendant put on an expert to testify that Miller’s injuries from the accident were treated and resolved. Miller challenged this expert’s testimony as a “mere conclusion” of a credential witness. That is, that this witness is qualified as an expert but his opinion was not based upon the correct foundation of knowledge and research into Miller’s condition. The court of appeals ruled against Miller on this issue as well and upheld the experts testimony.

Ultimately the Dallas court of appeals upheld the jury’s verdict and denied Miller’s appeal.

If you have been injured in a Rockwall Car Accident call our car accident and injury team.

Client Reviews
★★★★★
Guest and Gray law firm is wonderful. I have had the chance to work with three of the lawyers and they all have been wonderful. They will tell you when you need a lawyer and when you don't. They actually try to save you money. They respond very fast to questions and try to help you understand what is going on. They are caring and are really judgment free. If I needed a lawyer again I would use this firm in a second and recommend them. K.K.
★★★★★
I used Guest and Gray to deal with my ex wife's accusations of child neglect.I dealt with Robert Guest and Tracy Gray. Both were excellent attorneys and surpassed every expectation I had in fighting the false accusations. We Won ! M.B.
★★★★★
I used Guest & Gray for a child custody case and they were great. I was really nervous about the case but they took care of everything and answered all my questions. I would recommend their services to anyone. J.R.
★★★★★
I can highly recommend Guest and Gray. I have worked on a number of cases with Robert Guest and and Scott Gray and find it amazing how MOTIVATED they are to do everything they can for their clients, not to mention that there superior knowledge, etc. In criminal cases supportive relatives always want to know "what can I do" to help. Hire Guest and Gray. C.S.